It takes as much energy to wish as it does to plan. 

(Eleanor Roosevelt) 

Life happens

One of the silver linings to the pandemic has been its ability to highlight the value of an emergency fund in swift, stark terms.  However, as with many big life and financial lessons, the learning often fades as the crisis recedes or people learn to live with the new normal.  But, the best time to plan is before another crisis hits.  And, the best reason to plan is so you can withstand future crises as they inevitably arise.  So, as sort of a post-mortem (no pun intended), now  is a good time to reflect on the role an emergency fund in navigating life.   

When it comes to an emergency fund, most people are familiar with it; some see the value of it; few a have a sufficient amount of it.  Before diving in too deep, let’s define emergency fund.  It’s essentially a certain amount of cash set aside to address life’s common misfortunes: car breakdown, leaky roof, medical emergency, unforeseen tax bill, job loss, death in the family, etc.  The typical American household has $8,863 in cash.[1] Below is the average cash holding for different age groups.[2]  Where do you fall in the mix? 

 

Median balance of emergency fund by age groups

 

Value of an emergency fund  

Regardless of whether or not you have an emergency fund, it’s important to recount its benefits and, therefore, its value within your financial “toolbox.”

Time:  An emergency fund buys you precious time to process your new situation; research potential alternatives or workarounds; find a viable replacement; grieve a loss.  Ultimately, this stash of cash enables you to make the best decision for yourself and loved ones within a short(er) period of time.   

 

Insurance:  An emergency fund is a form of self-funded insurance that helps prevent an unforeseen inconvenience from becoming a catastrophe.  For example, if your car breaks down, an emergency fund helps you either to fix it or to buy a replacement rather than face the possibility of losing your job due to the lack of transportation.       

 

Interest savings:  Although modern life offers a number of alternative (and creative) ways to access cash quickly, convenience is often costly.  Here are the average annual interest rates charged for different forms of borrowing.  

·       Credit Card: 15%-20% (depending on credit score) 

·       Retirement accounts (hardship withdrawal):  Income tax and 10% penalty on distribution

·       Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC):  5%   

Unfortunately, in trying to solve one problem, you inadvertently create bigger problems down the line.  Take credit cards for instance.  A interest charge of 15% can turn a $5,000 loan into a $10,000 loan in a 5-year period (assuming minimum payments).  Meanwhile, an interest charge of 5% can double a loan amount over a 15-year period.  Convenience can become very inconvenient sometimes very quickly.  

 

Growth:  An emergency fund offers you the financial and psychological buffer needed to stay invested in the market in order to benefit from the (eventual) rebound, capital appreciation and compounding.  When you borrow or withdraw from your retirement savings account to address personal emergencies or fund living expenses, you temporarily or permanently forego the future growth of your retirement savings.  Seven percent is the average annualized return for a 70/30 portfolio.  A 7% return will double your portfolio over a 10-year period. 

How much to put aside?  

The general rule-of-thumb is to put aside 3 months of cash for dual-income households and 6 months for single-income households.  However, I personally recommend 9-12 months for my single female clients, especially if they have dependents.  There are numerous studies that argue against holding too much cash, foremost being opportunity cost.  Theoretically, you could invest additional savings in the market for potentially higher returns.  However, my view on an emergency fund is similar to paying off one’s mortgage in order to live mortgage free, especially if you intend to stay in the home for a long time (10 years plus).  Comparing average investment return with greater peace of mind is a case of apples versus oranges. Truth is, financial strength is built on having a combination of both. Moreover, they mutually strengthen each other.    

Where to put your emergency fund?

I recommend putting emergency fund in a high-interest online savings account (e.g., Ally Bank, Capital One 360).  While some people prefer to put a portion of their emergency fund in a money market account or short-term CDs to eke out a little more interest, I see a high-interest online savings account as a good compromise among conflicting needs: preservation of purchasing power (interest); safety (FDIC insured); liquidity (cash).   

How to save for it? 

Consider redirecting 15% of every paycheck to an online savings account until you have reached your target amount.  At fifteen percent, you can build up a sufficient emergency fund over a short(er) period of time without being forced to make radical lifestyle changes.  

Final thoughts

In art, there’s a technique that leverages negative space (typically black) to highlight the profiled object.  When it comes to an emergency fund, we often don’t see its true value until viewed against an emergency and compared with alternatives, which often carry greater financial and emotional costs.  However, given the unpredictability of life, an emergency fund provides the small, but critical, space needed to respond versus react.  While the former is a decision, the latter is a reflex.  And, oftentimes, that makes all the difference between success and failure.  As is, an emergency fund is really an agency fund.     

 


[1] “This chart shows how much money Americans have in savings at every age,” CNBC, March 2019.

[2] “Here’s how much the typical American has saved in cash, at every age,” Business Insider, March 2020. 

 

RECENT POSTS

Stage with red curtains and sets of a town

August steep market decline serves as a useful dress rehearsal for how we might react in a bear market and what we should do now to increase survival.

A young woman reading a book while sitting on a ledge near the window.

We often look to books for answers to Life’s persistent questions. However, these three books reveal that contradictions can reflect a higher truth than mere beliefs in this or that.

A red and white striped windsock blowing in the wind while planted in the middle of a green field

Given 2023 stock market’s reversal of 2022 decline, I want to share my thoughts on markets and money by highlighting potential risks and returns to help you chart your financial course forward.

Get a free financial education.

Learn more about key financial topics, such as investing, 401k, disability insurance, paying for a home, at your own convenience. Sign up for Women’s Wealth monthly newsletter and have relevant information delivered to your inbox.